Let me tell you about the Sunday I walked into a church in North Carolina and accidentally became the most controversial woman in the building — simply by existing.
I was visiting from Glendale, California — Los Angeles, for those who need the full picture — and feeling a pull toward something familiar. Southern Black church culture has a particular warmth to it, a particular sound, a particular way of making you feel like you are exactly where you are supposed to be. I was nostalgic. I was open. I said to myself: what the heck. Let me find a church I've never attended before.
The church was in the Durham/Chapel Hill area — the same region where I earned my undergraduate degree. Familiar ground. I arrived, lipstick on, dressed like myself, ready to receive a word.
"the parking attendants were gracious. the ushers were gracious. then i reached the pews — and all heck broke loose."
The parking attendants greeted me warmly. The ushers at the front door were gracious and kind. I made my way toward the pews — and that is where the temperature changed.
A few women seated nearby began giving me looks. Not the curious kind. The territorial kind. Through what I can only describe as God's gift of discernment, I sensed the insecurity almost immediately. I was not looking for trouble. I was looking for a seat and a sermon.
I later learned the source of the tension: the pastor — a man well over sixty, single for roughly a decade — had apparently inspired a quiet competition among certain women in the congregation. And somehow, without my knowledge or consent, I had been cast as a contestant.
I was in my early thirties. I was in a loving relationship with a man on the West Coast. I had driven to this church for the Word — not for the pastor. And yet, because I was a woman of God who also happened to be attractive, the assumption had already been made. I was his. I must belong to someone powerful in this room.
This was not an isolated incident. It happened again at a BET event in Miami — though the energy there was entirely different. The women were warm, friendly, genuinely lovely. One older woman leaned over to me with a conspiratorial smile and whispered: "Are you [gospel singer's] wife?"
What she did not know — what she could not have known — was that said gospel singer is a close acquaintance of mine. And as gay as the day is long.
I say this not to embarrass anyone, but to illustrate a pattern. In the church, in entertainment spaces, in rooms where powerful men are present — a polished, feminine, attractive woman is rarely seen as simply herself. She is seen as an extension of someone else. An accessory. A plus-one who must belong to the most prominent man in the room.
"just because i am a woman of god who happens to be attractive does not mean i am automatically the main attraction's girlfriend."
Men, I blame you. Not entirely — but significantly. Because the assumption that an attractive, feminine, polished woman must belong to a man in the room is not a female invention. It is a cultural inheritance, and men have done very little to dismantle it.
A woman can walk into a sanctuary, a gala, a boardroom — dressed with intention, wearing her full face, carrying herself with grace — and still be there entirely for herself. For God. For the music. For the moment. Her presence is not an invitation to be claimed. Her beauty is not a signal of availability. Her lipstick is not a question waiting for your answer.
I have been in a loving relationship. I have been single. In both seasons, I have been mistaken for someone's woman simply because I showed up looking like myself. The lipstick was on in both cases. It will remain on in all future cases.
And now that I am single? Well. Good luck out there.

About the Author
Lenai Butterfield
Founder of Lipstick Digest. Writer, believer, and unapologetic wearer of red lipstick. She writes about beauty, faith, confidence, and the radical act of being fully yourself.
more stories worth reading
All Articles